Sandra Waldie has a special connection to Lake Muskoka’s historic Beaumaris region. Not only does she cultivate a deep understanding and appreciation of the area’s storied history, she has also been involved in the sale of almost every Beaumaris island that has changed ownership in the last 25 years. These include Marco, Crete, Dorwood, Old Woman, Chaynemac, Turner, Urania, and Hepburn Islands. She and her daughter, Samantha, have also represented the sale of landmark properties on Gibraltar, Fairholm, Buck, Keewaydin to name a few, and the majority of delightfully historic golf-cart and drive-to access properties across the Beaumaris landscapes.
Sandy and her sales partner and daughter, Samantha, both service all Muskoka-area lakes and over the many decades have indubitably represented most of the finest and most iconic landmark mainland and island estates across Lakes Rosseau, Joseph, and Muskoka. “We love the majesty and exclusivity of grand sweeping island shores and a whole private island,” says Samantha. “They have so much to excite the imagination.” Together, the Waldie girls are excited to tour HIDEAWAYS readers around two extraordinary Beaumaris neighbourhood islands this year.
“This year’s properties represent two ideals,” says Sandy, who has been the number one Port Carling agent for Chestnut Park for the last 29 years. “On David Island, you will find the ultimate Beaumaris package of beautifully maintained historic buildings nestled in a charmed, storybook-like setting. Then, on Cedar Island, you have the idyllic landscape of centuries’ old forest and sparkling waters making the perfect canvas for someone to create and bring to life their own cottage island vision.”
First on our tour is David Island, situated in the heart of the enchanting Beaumaris private islands corridor. Here, a historic retreat overflows with characteristic charm and timeless elegance. Perfectly positioned amidst the serene waters of Lake Muskoka in the richly historied Beaumaris enclave, this private island estate is a haven for those seeking the quintessential family summerside getaway.
The property’s well-maintained and delightful family cottage boasts four bedrooms and three baths, and is a masterwork of fairytale design, with basswood-lined walls, sunset living and dining areas, and a stunning central-feature stone fireplace. Seamlessly blending old-world charm with modern comforts, the design facilitates easy flow of movement between living and entertaining areas, as well as providing private nooks, perfect for quiet reflection and daydreaming over lakeside views. Outside, a sweeping stone walkway winds its way to a five-slip (two indoors) boathouse.
The boathouse features a languorous pied-à-terre on the upper level, with three bedrooms, a living room, full bath, and sun-drenched lounging veranda, providing ample space for guests to unwind, savour their privacy, and enjoy the tranquility of island living. A guest cabin studio offers additional accommodation options, ensuring there’s room for everyone to escape and indulge in whatever pastime captures their fancy.
Building exteriors are clad with characteristic Beaumaris brown shingles, adding to the island’s sense of continuity and appeal. One of the highlights of the property is a grand west-facing stone sunset terrace that provides the perfect setting for evening drinks or al fresco dining whilst being gifted mesmerizing and forever-casting water views. An L-shaped sunset swim dock and toddler-friendly swim area provide a range of options for water lovers of different ages and aims.
An unbelievable combination of historic charm and ageless vibrancy, this island gem promises to captivate hearts and imaginations.
Next, the Waldie girls bring us to Cedar Island. Nestled in the southwest corridor of Beaumaris, anchored amidst the iconic islands of Old Woman and Stonewall, a hidden treasure awaits discerning buyers seeking a slice of paradise steeped in history and natural splendour. Cedar Island is a pristine oasis boasting approximately 3.5 acres of island privacy and enchanting vistas, now available for the first time in its storied history since the original land grant in 1874.
Once owned by renowned wooden boat builder Clive Brown, this exclusive property, with its distinguished address and rich heritage spanning five generations of family ownership, exudes a timeless allure that captivates the imagination. As you set foot on this historic isle, you are transported to a bygone era, where the winds carry echoes of summers past and the untouched beauty of Muskoka’s natural splendour takes centre stage. Three simple cottages dot the property, charmingly named Brownwyn, Blink Bonnie, and Cedar Lee.
A majestic forest canopy covers the island, offering sanctuary and serenity. Meandering pathways crisscross the landscape, bringing one from rocky western sunset points to sheltered swim coves to pristine sand beaches. For water enthusiasts, the island’s shoreline also boasts deeper waters ideal for diving and docking. Practically every vantage point promises endlessly pleasing views across Lake Muskoka.
The island’s shore includes both deep and shallow water entry points, ideal for water sports and swimmers of all ages. Look forward to many beautiful beach sunsets.
Nearby to Walkers Point, this prime location is perfect for those who appreciate the romance and history of Beaumaris, offering a rare opportunity to own a piece of Muskoka’s illustrious past.
Whether you dream of crafting your own island paradise or simply yearn for a tranquil retreat, Cedar Island is the ideal canvas upon which to bring your vision to life. With its pure privacy and unparalleled natural beauty, this historic gem is not just a property—it’s a legacy waiting to be passed down for generations to come.
Only two hours north of Toronto, Cedar Island promises escape and the chance to discover the timeless charm of Muskoka living at its finest.
Chestnut Park Real Estate Limited, Brokerage
110 Medora Street, P.O. Box 444, Port Carling, Ontario P0B 1J0
Sandy: Cell (705) 646-4747 • Office: 705-765-6878 • [email protected]
Samantha: Cell (705) 706-3350 • Office: 705-765-6878 • [email protected]
